What a Super El Niño Means for a Chicago Winter: Every Strong El Niño Winter in O’Hare’s Record Came In Milder Than the Trend. Weak Ones, on Average, Didn’t

What a super El Nino means for a Chicago winter: every strong El Nino winter in O'Hare's record since 1958 came in milder than the trend, with less snow, while weak ones, on average, didn't.

This page includes links to products on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

All seven winters in O’Hare’s record since 1958 that had a strong El Niño came in milder than the warming trend predicts for their year, calling for about 9 percent less heating than a typical winter of their time, with December through February averaging 4.4°F above its own trend line. Weak El Niños, on average, didn’t do it. This year’s El Niño is on course to be very strong, and NOAA gives it about a 60 percent chance of becoming the strongest in a record that starts in 1950.

NOAA’s daily record at O’Hare, 68 winters from 1958–59 to 2025–26 · NOAA Climate Prediction Center indexes and outlooks, October and November 2026 · the comparisons and the theory are ours

What is a super El Niño?

It’s the popular name for a very strong El Niño, and it isn’t one of NOAA’s categories. El Niño is a warming of the surface of the equatorial Pacific Ocean. NOAA’s Climate Prediction Center grades it by how far a stretch of the east-central equatorial Pacific, called Niño 3.4, runs above normal over three months: weak from 0.5°C, moderate from 1.0, strong from 1.5 and very strong from 2.0. The center now leads with a relative index, the RONI, which subtracts the warming of the whole tropical ocean so that a hotter planet doesn’t make every El Niño look stronger. The older Oceanic Niño Index, the ONI, is still published.

This one is big. On November 12 the center said a strong-to-very strong El Niño was likely to last through January–March 2027. It put the odds of a historic event, a relative-index reading of +2.5°C or more that no El Niño since 1950 has reached, at about 60 percent for October–December and November–January, and its strength table gives December through February a 79 percent chance of being very strong, +2.0 or more. The ONI already read +2.46 for August through October, a value only the 2015–16 event has topped; the RONI read +1.97, and the center calls its newest values estimates.

What does El Niño mean for a Chicago winter?

If it’s strong, it has meant a milder one in every case on O’Hare’s record so far. We measured each winter, November through March, in heating degree days, the standard gauge of how much heat the weather calls for: a day averaging 30°F counts 35, a day at 65 or warmer counts zero. Chicago’s winters have been getting milder, by about 113 degree days a decade since 1958, so we compared each winter with the trend line for its year rather than with one fixed average.

Seven winters had a strong El Niño, +1.5 or more on either index for December through February: 1965–66, 1972–73, 1982–83, 1991–92, 1997–98, 2015–16 and 2023–24. All seven came in below the trend, by 213 to 681 degree days, about 450 on average. Is that luck? In the whole record 37 of 68 winters landed on the mild side. If strong El Niños made no difference, and seven of the 68 winters had been picked at random, the chance that all seven would be mild ones is about one in 90. Nor does it depend on how the warming is taken out: against a 31-year running average, or against no trend at all, all seven still come out milder. And they aren’t bunched in recent, warmer years; the middle one is 1991–92.

The closest call the other way sits just under our cutoff. In 2009–10 the El Niño reached +1.5 on both indexes for November through January, then read +1.47 on the older index and +1.44 on the relative one for December through February. That winter came in about on the trend, with 54 inches of snow.

What does a strong El Niño’s mildness look like? Mostly, the deep cold goes missing. Those winters averaged 5 nights at or below zero, against about 10 in other winters; 31 days that never got above freezing, against 47; and 39 afternoons of 50 degrees or warmer, against 32. NOAA’s seasonal outlook of October 15 put the highest odds of a warmer than normal November through January over the upper Mississippi Valley and the Great Lakes, which it called consistent with strong El Niño events, and carried the pattern into later winter; its next outlook is due November 19.

−1,000−5000+500+1,000← milder than the trendcolder than the trend →La Niña (27)2011–12: −947 heating degree days against the trend2011–121975–76: −755 heating degree days against the trend1999–00: −547 heating degree days against the trend1998–99: −385 heating degree days against the trend2016–17: −363 heating degree days against the trend1973–74: −346 heating degree days against the trend1967–68: −296 heating degree days against the trend2022–23: −290 heating degree days against the trend1974–75: −271 heating degree days against the trend2020–21: −236 heating degree days against the trend2005–06: −201 heating degree days against the trend1970–71: −157 heating degree days against the trend2024–25: −136 heating degree days against the trend1988–89: −118 heating degree days against the trend1971–72: −101 heating degree days against the trend2021–22: −4 heating degree days against the trend2025–26: +25 heating degree days against the trend2012–13: +46 heating degree days against the trend1964–65: +228 heating degree days against the trend2017–18: +256 heating degree days against the trend1984–85: +298 heating degree days against the trend2007–08: +437 heating degree days against the trend2010–11: +486 heating degree days against the trend2008–09: +508 heating degree days against the trend1983–84: +584 heating degree days against the trend1995–96: +590 heating degree days against the trend2000–01: +656 heating degree days against the trendNeither (16)2001–02: −617 heating degree days against the trend1960–61: −301 heating degree days against the trend1966–67: −227 heating degree days against the trend1989–90: −184 heating degree days against the trend1980–81: −127 heating degree days against the trend2003–04: −24 heating degree days against the trend1959–60: +89 heating degree days against the trend1969–70: +132 heating degree days against the trend1961–62: +152 heating degree days against the trend1996–97: +322 heating degree days against the trend1993–94: +345 heating degree days against the trend1985–86: +361 heating degree days against the trend1962–63: +399 heating degree days against the trend1981–82: +537 heating degree days against the trend1978–79: +571 heating degree days against the trend2013–14: +1,161 heating degree days against the trend2013–14Weak El Niño (13)1990–91: −286 heating degree days against the trend2019–20: −139 heating degree days against the trend2006–07: −131 heating degree days against the trend2004–05: −100 heating degree days against the trend1987–88: −29 heating degree days against the trend1979–80: +19 heating degree days against the trend1992–93: +137 heating degree days against the trend1958–59: +171 heating degree days against the trend2002–03: +315 heating degree days against the trend1976–77: +495 heating degree days against the trend2018–19: +510 heating degree days against the trend1977–78: +660 heating degree days against the trend2014–15: +778 heating degree days against the trend2014–15Moderate (5)1994–95: −394 heating degree days against the trend1986–87: −389 heating degree days against the trend1968–69: −167 heating degree days against the trend2009–10: +13 heating degree days against the trend1963–64: +115 heating degree days against the trendStrong (3)2023–24: −681 heating degree days against the trend2023–241972–73: −414 heating degree days against the trend1965–66: −346 heating degree days against the trendVery strong (4)1982–83: −504 heating degree days against the trend2015–16: −486 heating degree days against the trend1997–98: −481 heating degree days against the trend1991–92: −213 heating degree days against the trend
Every strong El Niño winter at O’Hare came in milder than the trend Each dot is a winter, November through March, placed by its heating degree days minus the long-term trend line for its year. Rows by the December–February reading of NOAA’s two El Niño indexes; the El Niño rows use the higher of the two.

For a household, a winter that calls for about 9 percent less heat means a smaller gas bill, other things equal. This winter’s bill forecast is on our Chicago heating bills page.

Does El Niño mean more snow in Chicago?

Less, if it’s strong. Six of the seven strong El Niño winters have a complete snowfall record at O’Hare (1997–98 doesn’t). They brought a median 27.5 inches, and none more than 31.2, against a median of about 36 inches in the other 58 complete seasons. They had fewer snowy days, too: a median of 8 days with an inch or more, against 11.

Fewer snowy days isn’t the same as no big snow, though. Half of the six still had at least one day of 6 inches or more; of the other 58, 34 did. Every winter’s total is on our Chicago snowfall totals page.

What about a weak El Niño, or a La Niña winter?

Here the record turns odd. Weak El Niños, +0.5 to +1.0, didn’t make Chicago’s winters milder; on either index they ran colder than the trend on average, by 150 degree days on the older index and 233 on the relative one. Two weak El Niño winters, 2014–15 and 1977–78, rank as the second- and third-coldest against the trend in O’Hare’s whole record. The coldest, 2013–14, had neither El Niño nor La Niña.

Does La Niña, the cool phase of the same Pacific cycle, make Chicago winters harsher? Not on this record. Its 27 winters averaged 39 degree days milder than the trend, 16 milder and 11 colder. The mildest winter against the trend in the whole record, and the mildest outright, at 3,931 degree days, was 2011–12, a La Niña winter. The two snowiest seasons, 1978–79 at 83.7 inches and 2013–14 at 82.0, came in years with neither.

What a mild El Niño winter still brings

One thing a strong El Niño hasn’t changed is the number of freeze-thaw days, the ones that drop below freezing at night and climb above it by afternoon, so that slush melts and refreezes. Strong El Niño winters averaged 63 of them; other winters, 63. What changed is when they came. February averaged 15 freeze-thaw days in a strong El Niño winter against 12 in others, and March 12 against 15. That’s a pattern in seven winters, not a forecast: in a strong El Niño winter, the thawing and refreezing that usually belongs to March has tended to arrive in February.

051015Nov. strong El Niño winters: 11.4 freeze-thaw days on average11Nov. other winters: 11.9 freeze-thaw days on average12Nov.Dec. strong El Niño winters: 13.1 freeze-thaw days on average13Dec. other winters: 13.5 freeze-thaw days on average14Dec.Jan. strong El Niño winters: 11.9 freeze-thaw days on average12Jan. other winters: 10.6 freeze-thaw days on average11Jan.Feb. strong El Niño winters: 15.1 freeze-thaw days on average15Feb. other winters: 11.7 freeze-thaw days on average12Feb.March strong El Niño winters: 11.7 freeze-thaw days on average12March other winters: 15.1 freeze-thaw days on average15March7 strong El Niño winters61 other winters
Same number of freeze-thaw days, a month earlier Average days per month at O’Hare with a low below 32°F and a high above 32°F, 1958–59 to 2025–26.

Our theory: a switch, not a dial

Here is our reading, and it is our theory, not a finding. El Niño works on a Chicago winter less like a dial that turns smoothly from zero than like a switch. Below about +1.0, there’s no sign of it in O’Hare’s record. Somewhere around +1.0 it flips, and past that, each step up in strength has added less. Read on either index alone, going from weak to moderate moved the average winter about 391 to 484 degree days toward mild; moderate to strong, another 130 to 196; strong to very strong, 41 to 54. That last step is small next to how much one winter differs from the next.

Why would a weak El Niño not register at all? Our guess, and it is only a guess: NOAA says El Niño shifts the Pacific jet stream south and east. A weak one may shift it too little to stand out against the other things that steer a Chicago winter, like outbreaks of Arctic air, which El Niño only nudges. These records can’t confirm that.

  • On the recordFor it: on both indexes, weak El Niño winters averaged colder than the trend and every winter at +1.5 or more came in milder; on both, the moderate winters already leaned mild; and on both, the gains shrank with each step up.
  • On the recordAgainst it: the groups are small, two to 14 winters each, from one weather station. A straight line fits the 25 El Niño winters about as well, at roughly 377 degree days milder for each degree of Niño 3.4 warmth. 2009–10, just under the strong cutoff, came in on the trend. And three winters change groups with the index: 1965–66 is strong only on the relative index, 2023–24 only on the older one, and 1991–92 is very strong only on the relative index.
  • Not establishedAlso unsettled: this winter differs from the last two very strong ones in other ways. NOAA’s outlook notes that a cool phase of a longer Pacific pattern, the Pacific Decadal Oscillation, remains in place; 1997–98 and 2015–16 came in its warm phase, though NOAA expects it to matter little this winter next to so strong an El Niño.

What would weaken it?

This winter puts part of it to a first test. By the trend line, a typical 2026–27 winter at O’Hare would call for about 4,710 heating degree days. The seven strong winters came in 213 to 681 below their trend, which would put this one at about 4,030 to 4,500. If it comes in at or above the trend, a strong El Niño will have failed to deliver a milder Chicago winter for the first time by our cutoff, and that would count against the theory. If it lands far below the range, milder than 2011–12’s record 3,931, it would favor the dial over the switch. One winter can’t settle either; the theory’s other half, that weak El Niños don’t soften Chicago’s winters, waits for the next weak one. NOAA’s daily record will have this winter’s total in early April 2027.

What these records can’t tell you

  • On the recordHow each winter since 1958 went at O’Hare, day by day, and how warm the Pacific ran each December through February.
  • Not establishedThis winter’s weather. A tilt in the seasonal odds isn’t a forecast for any week, and the lakefront and the suburbs run differently from O’Hare.
  • Not establishedWhether it matters where in the Pacific the warmth sits. This El Niño is warmest in the east, off South America: NOAA’s November 12 discussion had +4.4°C in the Niño 1+2 region there against +2.5 in Niño 3.4. We checked whether the difference between the Niño 3 region in the east and Niño 4 in the central Pacific explained Chicago’s El Niño winters beyond their strength; once strength was counted, it added nothing we could measure.
  • Not establishedPotholes. Because freeze-thaw days move toward February, we checked 311 pothole complaints. Across 14 winters the monthly count doesn’t follow O’Hare’s freeze-thaw days, so we make no pothole forecast. Complaints peaked in March in 11 of the 14 winters; 2023–24, a strong El Niño winter, was one of the two that peaked in February, while 2015–16 peaked in March.

How we counted

  • Weather. NOAA’s Global Historical Climatology Network daily record for O’Hare (station USW00094846): daily high, low and snowfall, downloaded October 8, 2026. A winter runs November 1 to March 31 and counts only if 95 percent of its days have both a high and a low; all 68 from 1958–59 to 2025–26 do. Heating degree days are 65 minus the day’s average of high and low, when positive, summed over the winter. The trend is a straight least-squares line of heating degree days against year; a winter’s departure is its total minus the line’s value for that year, and December–February temperatures are compared with their own trend line the same way. A freeze-thaw day has a low below 32 and a high above 32. Snow seasons run July to June and count when 95 percent of days carry a snowfall reading; 64 do.
  • El Niño. The Climate Prediction Center’s Oceanic Niño Index and relative index, December–February values. Strong means +1.5 or more on either; very strong, +2.0 or more on either; weak or moderate, +0.5 or more on either and below 1.5 on both; La Niña, −0.5 or less on either and no El Niño reading; the rest are neither. Strong is the same rule as on our heating bills page. Classes use the two-decimal values in the center’s data files, which its tables round to one decimal; 2009–10’s December–February ONI of +1.47 shows there as 1.5. The theory section reads each index alone, with weak from +0.5, moderate from +1.0, strong from +1.5 and very strong from +2.0. The strength and location checks used the center’s monthly Niño 3, Niño 4 and Niño 3.4 readings, December–February averages, in least-squares fits across the 25 El Niño winters. The 31-year running average for the robustness check is centered on each winter, shortened at the ends of the record.
  • Potholes. Pothole complaints to 311 from the city’s 2009–2018 file and current file, duplicates left out, counted by month for the winters 2011–12 to 2025–26; the older file holds almost no complaints before late 2010. 2018–19 is left out because the older file ends in December 2018 and the newer one is thin until February 2019. Each month’s share of the winter’s November–April complaints was compared with its freeze-thaw days.
  • Documents. The center’s ENSO discussion of November 12, 2026, its strength probabilities of November 2026 and its seasonal outlook discussion of October 15, 2026, to be superseded by the next on November 19, 2026.

ON AMAZON

For a mild or a snowy winter

Browse Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Computed by KCM Desk from NOAA’s daily weather record for O’Hare, NOAA Climate Prediction Center indexes and outlooks, and Chicago 311 records, read November 17, 2026. Human-guided and edited — about this desk. If you spot an error, corrections come first.

Moving HereLiving HereCity in MotionNeighborhoods & Suburbs
About · Editorial Policy · Our Data & Methods · Privacy · Terms · Contact
© 2026 Keep Chicagoland Moving · A TAK Marketing, LLC publication · Part of the fabulous Omnishun information systems